The Craigslist Guy

© by Bonnie

This happened just before Craigslist took down personal ads. I was living with my then-boyfriend, who was at this time obsessed with filming me in different situations. He would film me flashing truckers, nude at the beach, and answering the door semi-nude for the pizza guy. I was 39 at the time, no kids white, 5’4, 130 lbs with blonde highlights, and because it was summer, very tanned.

He asked me if he could film me having sex with different people. I, for some reason, thought this might be fun. I asked him where he would find someone, and he said Craigslist. So he showed me different ads for a few days but one I liked. He was 32 looks nice but had a large pink cock; I liked the color, maybe because my boyfriend was Hispanic. He called him and explained what he wanted to do. Of course, the Craigslist guy was all for it so that he would come over on Saturday.

My boyfriend wanted to film this in our backyard, in the patio area with many bushes along the fence very private. So Saturday afternoon came and I was nervous so I had a few drinks. A pickup pulled up, and he stepped out, but a German with short hair not fixed jumped out, too. He said hi and was sorry he couldn’t find anyone to watch him; my boyfriend said no problem because we would be in the backyard anyway. So, after some small talk, we went to the backyard.

I was wearing a white sun dress with no underwear; he was wearing shorts and a t-shirt. My boyfriend, Mr. Director, had him remove his shorts and sit on the bench with me sitting next to him. He told me to start playing with him, and he started filming. I started rubbing his cock and noticed he had shaved his balls and around his cock. He did have a long cock, but he wasn’t getting hard. I told him I loved his pink color, which seemed to work because now he got hard. My boyfriend said kiss it, so I did then lick it, but I was looking at his balls, and maybe it was the drinks, but I started licking them. Nice and shaved, I surprised my boyfriend and started sucking and licking his balls. Now he was hard, so I started to suck his cock.

Meanwhile, his dog explored the yard but came over to see what was happening. To him, I was eating his master. He got close to my face, so I took his cock out of my mouth and offered it to him! I didn’t know what to do. The Craigslist guy said he doesn’t like cock. He told me to open my legs and see what he did. I look at my boyfriend, but he’s all for it! So I pulled up one leg and opened it up. He came up and took a sniff, and started licking my pussy. Wow, what a feeling he was hitting spots I had forgotten about; my boyfriend said, “Don’t forget about Craigslist guy,” so I started jerking his cock. Now my boyfriend says get on my knees in front of him and suck him. So I get up and put a towel down for my knees and start again on his cock, but the dog follows me over and now starts on my ass. This went on for a few minutes, and I came, but so did the Craigslist guy!  I had told him beforehand not to cum in my mouth, but with that tongue up my ass, I just swallowed as much as I could.

I kneeled with my head in his lap when I felt the dog’s front legs on my hips. He was trying to screw me. I started to protest, but I saw my boyfriend like this; I could feel his not-hard cock going in between my ass cheeks and rubbing my ass hole. It was not bad. So I played it up, moaning and wiggling. I opened my legs more and wiggled some more, but I guess I wiggled too much because then he found my hole and took off! It was amazing how fast he was pumping and then stopped and started blowing up like a balloon. Now he pulled out with a pop! and I came again.

I sat looking at the dog, who was now liking himself and said oh look, he has a big pink cock like you! Me and my big mouth, my boyfriend, look at the Craigslist guy, and I know what they’re thinking. I told my boyfriend not to film me so he put down the camera. I approach the dog and start rubbing him on his stomach, and he lies back. So with one hand on his stomach and the other holding his cock I started sucking him. The taste wasn’t that bad, so with those two looking at me, I put on a little show of it. I was moaning and almost had his whole cock in my mouth, but I guess I was doing it too well because now he came into my mouth!  With a man, you get a warning, but I guess dogs are different because his cock felt the same, but then there was cum, a lot, but I wasn’t swallowing this time, so I turned my head and spat it out.

But then there was my boyfriend on his knees, sticking his cock in my mouth; then I felt Craigslist guy’s cock rubbing my ass! I hoped he wouldn’t stick that thing in my ass, and he didn’t, but he fuck me good. They both came pretty close together, with my boyfriend first filling my mouth with cum again, but the Craigslist guy pulled out and came in between my ass cheeks! I said thanks for the mess, but he said wait, don’t move. He called his dog over, and he started to clean me up! He got every last drop, and I got to cum again!

We called the Craigslist guy a month later to see if he wanted to visit again, but his phone was disconnected!  Oh well.

The End

Contents